A spoken sentence is full of sounds that never make it into print. The ums, the ahs, the false starts, the repeated words, the places where a speaker trails off and begins again. When someone turns speech into a transcript, every one of those sounds forces a decision: keep it or drop it. There is no neutral choice. Both directions edit the speaker.
Baylor University’s transcription style guide makes a specific call on this. In its section on crutch words, filler words like uh and um are omitted from the transcript unless a use adds to the meaning. The guide reserves brackets for something narrower and more specific: words and notes that are not present on the recording but are added to the transcript. And it describes a workflow in which a first draft from a tool like MacWhisper is then audited and edited by hand.
That last detail matters more than it might seem. The first pass is not treated as final. The machine drafts, a person reads against the recording, and only then does the transcript count as a record.
Here I want to mark the line between what the guide says and what I am reading into it. The guide states the rules: drop the filler words unless they add meaning, put additions in brackets, audit by hand. What I take from those rules is my own reading. To me, a transcript is a reading aid more than a fingerprint. Its job is to carry what the person meant, clearly, and hesitation often does not help carry that meaning. A reader who sees every um in print may read a thoughtful person as hesitant or unsure, because print makes hesitation look like confusion, and I suspect that is part of why a careful guide drops them.
There is a cost to the opposite choice, the verbatim-everything transcript. It preserves the raw sound, but I think it can flatten a speaker into something they were not, more faithful to the sound and less faithful to the person. That is my judgment, and it is a concern rather than a claim the guide argues.
Which is why the honest thing is to disclose the choice. A reader should know whether they are reading a cleaned transcript or a verbatim one, and whether a human checked it or it came straight from a machine. The ums and ahs themselves matter less than the decision to be open about what was done with them.

The Campfire
CommentsThanks. Your comment is waiting for the desk. Once it is approved it appears here within about a minute.
Add a comment